When Good Leaders Go Bad: Avoiding the Pitfalls of Poor Management

Bad bosses are often the stars of our favourite TV shows and films — think of Miranda Priestly in The Devil Wears Prada or Bill Lumbergh in Office Space. They’re entertaining, larger-than-life caricatures who create tension and laughs. But outside of pop culture, the reality of a bad boss is far less amusing. For employees, a poor manager can turn a fulfilling job into a daily struggle, affecting morale, productivity, and even mental health.

What’s more worrying is that many leaders can unknowingly slip into bad-boss behaviours. According to leading workplace strategists, the line between a supportive manager and a difficult one can sometimes be surprisingly thin. The good news? Understanding these pitfalls is the first step to becoming a better leader.

How Good Leaders Become Bad Bosses — Without Realising It

Renowned organisational psychologist Dr Emma Harris explains, “Many leaders start with the best intentions but can fall into negative patterns, especially under pressure. Long hours, high expectations, and the constant demand to deliver can cause even the most well-meaning managers to become micromanagers, overly critical, or emotionally unavailable.”

Research supports this: a 2023 study by the Australian Workplace Relations Institute found that nearly 60% of employees had experienced stress linked to managerial behaviour, with 45% citing poor communication as a key issue.

Workplace expert and leadership coach Daniel Cho adds, “It’s important for managers to regularly reflect on their leadership style. Are they listening to their teams? Are they setting clear expectations? Or are they defaulting to control and criticism because of stress or fear of failure?”

The Devil in the Details: Common Traits of Bad Bosses

• Micromanagement: Constantly checking in and second-guessing employees can signal distrust and stifle creativity.

• Poor Communication: Ambiguity or lack of feedback leaves teams confused and frustrated.

• Inaccessibility: When leaders are too busy or aloof, employees feel unsupported.

• Unrealistic Expectations: Setting goals without considering workload can lead to burnout.

Lessons for Leaders: What to Do Instead

1. Prioritise Empathy and Listening: Genuine engagement with staff helps build trust and morale.

2. Set Clear, Realistic Goals: Transparency around what’s expected allows teams to focus and succeed.

3. Encourage Autonomy: Giving employees room to make decisions fosters innovation and ownership.

4. Model Work-Life Balance: Avoid sending emails at midnight or expecting immediate replies outside work hours.

Leadership expert Dr Harris sums it up: “Good leaders recognise their own pressures but don’t let these justify poor behaviour. Instead, they seek support, remain self-aware, and continuously work on improving how they lead.”

Conclusion

While bad bosses make for compelling drama, in real workplaces their impact is serious and often damaging. Fortunately, by learning from these examples and committing to self-awareness, any leader can avoid the pitfalls that turn good managers into bad bosses. The difference can mean a happier, healthier, and more productive workplace for everyone.

The post When Good Leaders Go Bad: Avoiding the Pitfalls of Poor Management appeared first on Small Business Connections.